Many Orlando Pirates supporters are pointing to a crucial tactical decision as the turning point in their 2-1 loss to Kaizer Chiefs in the Nedbank Cup final—substituting Makhehlene Makhaula.
With the score level at 1-1 in the 72nd minute, coach Jose Riveiro brought off Makhaula for Mohau Nkota. Meanwhile, Chiefs made their own changes, introducing Mduduzi Shabalala and Ashley Du Preez, which injected fresh energy into their attack. Just minutes later, Yusuf Maart netted the decisive goal that sealed Chiefs’ long-awaited trophy, ending a decade of silverware drought.
Pirates’ Midfield Lost Its Shape
While Amakhosi’s substitutions clearly made an impact, Pirates struggled to maintain control in the middle of the park after Makhaula’s exit. Fans on social media were quick to criticize the decision, believing it left a gap that Kaizer Chiefs capitalized on. One fan commented, “The same mistake that cost us the game in Cairo cost us today. You can’t take out Makhaula or Mbatha without a proper replacement who can defend and attack.”
Makhaula has been a standout performer for Pirates this season, praised for his work rate, aggression, and ability to break up opposition play. His absence was immediately felt as Pirates lost their shape and momentum.
Frustration from the Stands
Several fans vented their frustration online. One tweet read: “Replacing Makhaula was a bad idea,” while another added, “Maswanganyi should’ve been subbed off, not Makhaula. At least replace him with someone like Mosele who can hold the midfield.”
The loss has left Pirates fans reflecting on what could have been in a season filled with promise but ultimately short on major silverware.
