In a dramatic twist in the asbestos corruption trial, the court has ruled in favor of former Free State Premier Ace Magashule, granting his legal team the right to cross-examine lead investigator Captain Benjamin Calitz. The ruling marks a pivotal moment in one of South Africa’s most closely watched corruption cases.
The National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) had strongly opposed the application, arguing that cross-examination was unwarranted since there was no direct evidence linking Magashule to alleged incriminating statements made by Moroadi Cholota, his former personal assistant and co-accused. However, the judge dismissed the objection, stating that the defense had a right to test the credibility of the investigative process.
Magashule, who faces multiple charges related to a R255 million asbestos removal contract during his tenure as premier, has consistently denied any wrongdoing. His legal team argues that the state’s case is built on flawed interpretations and unreliable witness accounts — particularly those tied to Cholota, who initially cooperated with investigators but later became a co-accused.
Captain Calitz, a key figure in piecing together the prosecution’s case, is expected to face tough questions from Magashule’s lawyers, who aim to probe inconsistencies and alleged procedural missteps in the investigation.
Legal analysts say this development could significantly shift the courtroom dynamics, opening the door for new angles of defense and potentially weakening the state’s narrative.
As the trial continues, public interest remains high, with many seeing the outcome as a test of South Africa’s commitment to rooting out high-level corruption. The next round of testimony is expected to be both intense and revealing as the cross-examination unfolds in the coming days.
