Mamelodi Sundowns winger Thembinkosi Lorch has come under fire from the club’s supporters after posting a happy birthday message to former coach Rulani Mokwena, while wearing an Orlando Pirates jersey. The image, which dates back to their time at the Soweto giants, has sparked controversy among Sundowns fans, many of whom felt it was inappropriate given Lorch’s current association with the club.
Lorch and Mokwena both spent significant time at Pirates before making the move to Sundowns, with Lorch joining the Brazilians in January 2024. Despite his potential, Lorch has struggled to find his feet at Sundowns, often not being able to replicate the form that earned him the PSL Player of the Season award during his time with Pirates. Mokwena, on the other hand, left Sundowns to join Wydad AC, but their history at Pirates remained a shared bond.
The birthday post, which featured Lorch in a Pirates jersey, quickly drew the ire of Sundowns fans on social media. Many questioned Lorch’s loyalty, seeing the image as a sign that he may still have a strong connection to his former club. Some fans were particularly concerned about his intentions, especially given his struggles to secure a regular spot in the Sundowns starting lineup.
“Lorch should understand the importance of loyalty to Sundowns. This picture, and the message, could be seen as a sign that his heart is still in Orlando,” one fan commented on social media. Another supporter added, “Lorch owes his success to Pirates, but now that he’s with Sundowns, he needs to focus on his current club and forget the past.”
However, some local football fans came to Lorch’s defense, arguing that he had every right to post the picture, regardless of his current club affiliation. “Lorch is his own person and can use whatever photo he likes. His history at Pirates is part of his journey. He’s a Sundowns player now and should be judged by his performance here,” one fan pointed out.
Despite these defenses, the backlash highlights deeper concerns among Sundowns supporters about Lorch’s commitment to the club. Some feel that his struggles at Sundowns, combined with his social media post, could indicate a lack of focus or a possible longing for the past. Critics have gone as far as questioning whether Lorch is fully dedicated to his current role at Sundowns, especially as the club’s fans believe they need players who are entirely committed to the team’s ambitions.
One particularly harsh criticism, reflecting the dissatisfaction of some fans, read: “This shows where his heart is. Orlando Pirates took him out of poverty and made him the player he is today. We can’t rely on a player who might be longing for a club that pays less than he earns now. Sundowns deserves more loyalty.”
The situation has also raised questions about the future of Lorch at Sundowns. While his talent is undeniable, his position within the team could be at risk if fans and management perceive his commitment as wavering. The club is currently in a strong position to challenge for the league title, and fans are not willing to accept any distractions or divided loyalties, especially as Orlando Pirates are emerging as serious contenders this season.
As Sundowns prepare for the second half of the season, the club’s technical team, led by coach Rulani Mokwena, will likely be keeping a close eye on Lorch’s form and mentality. The winger’s ability to focus on his current team and deliver for Sundowns could determine whether his time at the club will be remembered for success or as a period of unfulfilled potential.
