Mamelodi Sundowns’ unexpected 2-1 defeat to Kaizer Chiefs in the Nedbank Cup semi-final has left many supporters and football pundits scratching their heads. What exactly went wrong for a team that has dominated local football for so long?
After the match, Sundowns coach Miguel Cardoso didn’t hold back his frustration, pointing out the PSL’s lack of VAR as a possible contributor to their downfall. “When you coach in a country without VAR, these things happen,” he said. But was that the only reason for Masandawana’s exit?
Tactical Calls Under the Microscope
Beyond the refereeing controversy, fans have also taken a closer look at the tactical decisions made by Cardoso. Many questioned the timing and choice of substitutions—especially the early removal of attacking threats Iqraam Rayners and Bathusi Aubaas. Their replacements, Arthur Sales and Jayden Adams, failed to make an impact and struggled to shift the momentum of the game.
With the spotlight now firmly on Sundowns’ bench, the club and its technical team will need to reflect deeply. Was it just a bad day at the office, or is there more to this shock cup exit?
